bookstore1.gif (6054 bytes)

Gulf War Vets Home Page


by Larry Scott

Posted Oct. 24, 2005

Bob started his email by saying, “They’re sending me back to hell again.” William wrote that he just put his home on the market thinking he’ll need the money to live on. Mary told me she’ll have to go back to work instead of staying home and caring for her husband.

Greg Morris, of Chama, New Mexico, didn’t send me an email. Morris, a Vietnam veteran, took out his gun and killed himself. At his side, next to his Purple Heart, was a folder containing information from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) describing the review of 72,000 Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) claims that had already been awarded.

All of these veterans have a common bond. They all suffer from PTSD. They all receive VA compensation. And, they all live in fear of losing the small amount of income their VA compensation offers.

All except Greg Morris, because he is not among the living. Morris was worried about losing his benefits. His PTSD counseling was triggering flashbacks. He had been told not to worry about the VA review because he had been wounded and that should mean his compensation award wouldn’t be reduced or canceled.

Morris had not received a letter from the VA telling him his PTSD award was being reviewed. But he, like many other veterans, must have felt that all awarded PTSD claims were in jeopardy.

The October 8 suicide of Greg Morris has received little attention in the press. Details came to light last week when Rep. Tom Udall (D-NM) testified before a hearing of the House Veterans' Affairs subcommittee on disability assistance. Udall said of Morris, "He believed, as so many veterans do, that he was being forced to prove himself again.”

The VA calls the review a “paper exercise” citing errors they made in granting the compensation. Spokespersons for the VA have consistently tried to downplay the significance of the review by reassuring veterans that they aren’t trying to take away any benefits.

But, Rep. Udall said while it might seem like a "paperwork review" to the VA, veterans with PTSD see it as a "personal attack" that will force them to relive the trauma to continue getting benefits. And, a VA compensation specialist told me “it’s all about money” and added, “We could save a few billion a year if we deny these guys’ claims.”

Adding to the anger and confusion among veterans is the VA’s complete lack of candor about the PTSD review process. No VA documents have surfaced indicating how the process is to be handled internally.

And, the VA keeps sending confusing signals to veterans about the review. VA centers in Arizona and South Dakota have told veterans’ groups that the review if off. This, while other VA officials have publicly stated that the review will continue “until someone tells us to stop.”

This indecision on the part of the VA has turned into a game of emotional ping-pong that is devastating many veterans who suffer from PTSD. They are asking: Is my claim valid? Will I have to prove everything all over again and relive the hell? Will they take away my compensation? And, if they do, what will I do?

If this review were truly a “paper exercise” as the VA claims, then it could be done on paper. The VA could analyze, without notifying veterans, any errors made in granting claims. Then they could lay out standardized guidelines for all claims processors so that these types of errors would not occur in the future. No one need know. Unless…unless the real goal is to cut costs by reducing and denying PTSD claims.

The VA’s total incompetence in handling the review of 72,000 PTSD claims would be laughable if 72,000 lives weren’t at stake. But, this is what veterans have come to expect from the agency set up to help and protect them.

A recent edition of New Republic magazine ranked VA Secretary Jim Nicholson #4 on the list of the top 15 political hacks bungling their way through government agencies. The VA, top-heavy with political appointees and inept cronies, is being “Mike Browned” and making enemies of those who fought our enemies.

I dearly hope that Bob does not go through hell again. I hope William does not have to sell his home. And Mary should be with her husband, to help him through the nightmare of PTSD, and not working.

It’s time for the VA to abandon this review of PTSD claims. It’s time for them to stop harassing those who have already given so much.

Greg Morris will probably never make the list of veterans we all know, like Audie Murphy and Alvin York. But, Greg Morris will stand as a solemn reminder to all veterans that there are still battles to be fought…that “friendly fire” is the most devastating fire of all…and that the VA, the government agency that should be “caring for those who serve and protect” is, once again, guilty of dereliction of duty.

Larry Scott ( ) served four years in the U.S. Army with overseas tours as a Broadcast Journalist in Korea and the Azores and a stateside tour as a Broadcast Journalism Instructor at the Defense Information School (DINFOS). He was awarded DOD's First Place Thomas Jefferson Award for Excellence in Journalism. After the Army, Larry was a news anchor on WNBC Radio in New York City. He receives VA compensation for a service-connected disability. Larry is a regular on the Thom Hartmann show on KPOJ radio in Portland, Oregon. Today, Larry resides in Southwest Washington and operates the website VA Watchdog.Org.